Opinion
Roy McKenzie
It’s Time to Deport Montana’s Housing Crisis
As mass deportations accelerate, Missoula must not be overlooked—it must be ground zero.
Mar 23, 2025

By Roy McKenzie
Opinion Contributor
Seventeen illegal aliens were arrested at a construction site in Bigfork earlier this month. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) reported on X they were “found to be inadmissible to the United States,” a bureaucratic phrase that masks a stark truth: they should not have been here in the first place.
Just weeks before the raid, Missoula Mayor Andrea Davis acknowledged in a meeting with the Montana Veterans Association that over 3,000 alien migrants had been placed in Missoula over the last four years. The MVA, with eyes on the ground and firsthand exposure to the crisis, estimates the true number is closer to 4,000.
In a city the size of Missoula, those numbers are not incidental. They are transformational. They represent thousands of non-citizens competing directly with Montanans for housing, public services, and jobs. And yet, this pressure point is all but ignored in the dominant narrative about Montana’s housing crisis. Instead, we are offered endless sermons about zoning reform, density, and the supposed evils of single-family homes.
Let us state plainly what many know but fear to say: Montana’s housing crisis is not simply a zoning issue—it is an invasion, coordinated and concealed by activists and subsidized by your government.
To understand how we arrived here, we must start with what we do know. Soft Landing Missoula, a local NGO partnered with the International Rescue Committee (IRC), announced at City Club in Missoula that they placed over 500 alien migrants in Missoula from 2016 to 2022. That figure spans both the restrictive Trump era and the early Biden years. If we generously assume a doubling or tripling of placements under Biden—as national immigration numbers would justify—then we estimate another 1,000 to 1,500 alien migrants arrived through official NGO channels since 2021.
But the true number is much higher. National immigration data from the Congressional Budget Office and Goldman Sachs show that over 7 million alien migrants entered the U.S. under Biden, with at least 4.3 million crossing illegally. If even a fraction of one percent found their way to Montana—not an unreasonable estimate—we’re talking about 7,000 to 12,000 new arrivals statewide. In Missoula, that easily supports the MVA’s 4,000 figure.
The Deportation Mandate Should Start in Missoula
This influx is not entering a housing market with room to spare. Missoula’s rental vacancy rate is 2.9%. Statewide, home vacancies sit at 0.8%. Median rent for a one-bedroom is $1,190. A family of four may easily spend over $20,000 a year just to stay housed. And yet, in this environment, thousands of alien migrants have been placed in our communities by design, under the management of activist NGOs and without the consent of those who live here.
The defenders of this policy regime—and it is a regime—will not talk about alien migration. Instead, they offer a coordinated misdirection. The Frontier Institute, Forward Montana, and other ideological bedfellows insist that the solution lies in eliminating zoning restrictions and prioritizing dense urban development. In 2023, they cheered a slate of bills passed by the Montana Legislature that opened the door to ADUs, duplexes, and “stackable” apartment-style units, often on formerly single-family lots. The media called it the “Montana Miracle.”
A miracle for whom? I call it A Bug’s Life.
Their argument goes something like this: If we do not build up, we will pave over our open space. But this framing conceals more than it reveals. It presumes that the demand is simply a natural consequence of economic growth or in-migration from other states—often blamed on conservative-leaning Americans fleeing blue-state decay—but avoids acknowledging the deliberate placement of tens of thousands of alien migrants as a core accelerant of that demand. Their analysis lacks a serious inquiry into how that demand was artificially inflated by a massive injection of alien migration, coordinated by federally funded NGOs like Soft Landing Missoula and the IRC.
We are not simply underbuilding. We are also overloading. And that distinction matters.
Nowhere is the entrenchment of NGO-driven failure more concentrated than at Missoula’s Johnson Street Shelter. Built during the pandemic with COVID-era federal funds, it was never intended as a permanent solution. And yet it became one, until the city announced its closure earlier this month, with depopulation already underway and full shutdown expected by August 2025.
What was billed as an emergency measure became an institutional dependency. The shelter served the non-profit ecosystem more than it served the homeless, feeding a complex of unaccountable service organizations that thrive on continued dysfunction. The result was predictable: rising homelessness, encampments spilling into residential neighborhoods, and increasing disorder.
Missoula’s political class claims this is about compassion. But real compassion requires prioritization. And what we see instead is a system that prioritizes those who arrive illegally over those who have served, worked, and contributed to this community for decades.
While the city shut down shelters and renters faced $1,500 leases, alien migrants continued to arrive during the Biden administration. While veterans are left unhoused, activists secure placements for alien migrants through bureaucratic workaround and legal euphemism. Missoula may not be a sanctuary city in name, but it has become one in effect—operated not by elected officials, but by non-profits that shield the city from accountability.
Deport Missoula’s Soft Landings
On Friday, President Trump announced plans to revoke temporary legal status for over 530,000 alien migrants brought into the country under Biden’s Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua, Venezuela (CHNV) sponsorship program. They have been encouraged to self-deport and warned to prepare for deportation.
Missoula should do the same—and more. It should demand removals, cheer for deportations, and reject the notion that housing policy must accommodate a lawless influx of aliens over its own citizens.
This is not cruelty. It is restoration. If Montana wants to reclaim its housing market, its public services, and its sense of social contract, then we must do more than build. We must remove the pressure. That means ending all NGO-facilitated placements of alien migrants in this state.
Not pausing. Ending.
These NGOs are not independent actors. They are tentacles—extensions of a broader, unelected regime funded by dark money foundations and fortified with taxpayer dollars. For decades, agencies like USAID funneled billions into activist networks that burrowed deep into local communities, bypassing voters and laundering federal policy through charitable fronts.
That era is ending. In its first week, the Trump administration—through Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency—dismantled USAID and began draining the swamp not just in Washington, but in every town it infected. This is not reform. It is extraction. Ripping it up from the root.
Nothing Can Stop What Is Coming
Uprooting the machine is only the beginning. What follows will require resolve. The NGOs will resist. The activists will mobilize. The foundations and media machines will paint every loss of power and every alien removal as a humanitarian collapse. But it will not be a collapse. It will be a course correction—long delayed, but finally underway.
We have seen only the beginning—the first signs of a national immune response to decades of engineered decay. Torchings. Vandalism. Character assassinations. Attempted physical assassinations. These are not cries for help or compassion. They are the flailing rage of a movement that believed its dominance was permanent. Conditioned by years of impunity and insulated by a now fading culture that rewarded emotional blackmail over lawful order, they now face a world that no longer yields.
Trump’s victory was not a whisper. It was a mandate—for removal, for reckoning, for restoration. Missoula must not merely brace for it. Missoula must embrace it. Support it. Fulfill it.
The left will cry. Let them. Their outrage is not a veto.
Mass deportation is not cruelty. It is the threshold of a golden age—and nothing can stop what is coming.
Roy McKenzie is the Publisher of Western Montana News, where he reports on local government, politics, and current events in Missoula County. His work includes coverage of local responses to key events, election integrity, and political developments shaping Western Montana.
Subscribe to our weekly email
Get these stories delivered to your inbox every Monday.
‘Illegal aliens’… there I fixed your editorial for ya
True 🙏
Not enough time to be original, but can add this great passage from an astute writer Rhyd Wildermuth: “This is something leftists all knew until class consciousness got replaced with the false enlightenment of social justice. Immigrants are not the enemy, but disruptive mass immigration is one of the enemy’s weapons. When a large group of us (remember — I’m an immigrant) move into a place, we will change it no matter whether we want to or not. This is even more true if the communities into which we move have already begun to fall apart through cultural erosion or economic damage.”. That last phrase reminds me of a Jensen quote (paraphrased): In order to have a tragedy of the commons, you’ve already had a tragedy of community.
Everyone should look at the Missoula Soft Landing website to understand the legal status of the refugee population they help. The other point to try to understand is that the mass migration (legal and illegal) we are seeing globally is a symptom of a much greater disease and it is only going to get worse if you only focus on short-term, false solutions like building walls around your community. Until you understand the roots of migration, you will keep putting band-aids on a malignant tumor.
Mass migration is not liberation—it is displacement. The same global interests that exploit the developing world now turn their sights inward, gutting communities like Missoula under the guise of “resettlement.”
NGOs and corporate-backed migration pipelines don’t “help” people—they destabilize nations, extract labor, and erase local cultures. If this were happening in South America, it would be called neo-colonialism. The only difference now? It is happening here.
A marketing website won’t change that. The question isn’t what Soft Landing says—it’s what it does. And what it does is import thousands of alien migrants into an overburdened community, while telling locals they have no right to object
Here is a good read for an old friend:
https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2018/11/the-left-case-against-open-borders/
You talk about jobs — really? I talked to a concrete contractor in Kalispell who said they tried paying a $25/day “show up bonus” — and she said that her husband couldn’t keep anyone past 3 days — but the Venzuelans showed up every single day. I guess when people cross through jungles, deserts, and thousands of miles in the heat, making out of their bed and to the jobsite isn’t that difficult for them either.
Seriously, when was the last time a Montanan was turned down from a job — and how many contractors built houses this last year, poured foundations, got tile jobs done because they put these people to work alongside American workers. Montana graduates flee the state for careers in the military and college. We’re #3 for exit by 18-24 year-olds. Alaska is #1.
Yes – I’m against crime and “turn them loose” DA’s. But they’re rounding up people who are following the rules and are checking in. They’re rounding up green card holders. If there was a crime, they could at least have a hearing and a trial and a sentence. But, none of us voted to turn American into El Salvador where people are disappeared, tortured, killed with zero accountability – no parole, no sentences, just $6 million a year into the president’s pocket.
Why not tell Venzuela and other countries – send your airlines every week – with extra flights – return people home in the next 6 months, try depoulating America — and see how many Americans show up to work the night shift in those Iowa and Arkansas chicken plants where Guatemalen kids work the night shifts and have no child labor or workers’ comp protection. Tear apart all these families, screw all those DACA kids in the military, colleges, and working as doctors and nurses. We’ll go from America the Great to America the Hated in short order.
For those who are Christians out there – google “Norwegian woman prophecy 1968” and see what was foretold about the wave of immigration in the world. It’s very interesting. For those who aren’t Christians, you may mock it because it talks about when Christ returns.
Interesting anecdote, Lisa. Perhaps you missed the line in the first sentence, “illegal aliens” meaning these individuals already broke the law attempting to unlawfully enter the United States. These individuals do not have a legal right to work in the United States.
What was the name of the contractor in Kalispell?
Stephen Miller likes turning LEGAL immigrants into illegal immigrants. 532,000 LEGAL Cuban, Venzuelan, and Haitian immigrants had their status revoked and were just given 30 days to leave the country. Their deadline was shortened from 18 months for a judge to hear their case, they’re all documented, they were using an app. Kristi Noem had announced that the app they were using has been turned into a self-deportation app this week. They disappeared a Phillipine woman with no criminal history who had a green card here for 50 years and went to her check-in last week. She hadn’t revoked her Phillipine citizenship because of family reasons over there. Now her family can’t find her because they’re putting people on flights to Central America who are from other countries and holding them in overseas detention centers in Panama as well as El Salvador.
He had the H2A program for farm workers shut down last time and that’s one that Montana ranchers have been using because there aren’t many folks that want to go be a farmhand in eastern Montana any more. Ranchers back there were having a lot of success with Peruvians and South Africans. It also hurts the farmers in a lot of other states who lost crops because of the cutbacks in ag workers.
The only class of immigrants that they are extending an invitation to are white South Africans (where Musk is from). I’m not against allowing them in. But they shut down all refugee resettlement and cut off aid to the Afghan allies program where the ones who helped us during the war there were being resettled after living in refugee camps overseas and being vetted.
And if you recall those chaotic scenes from the Afghan withdrawal, after Pompeo and Trump agreed to give the country back to Afghanistan in May 2021, they wouldn’t allow any Afghans to leave then either.
Interestingly enough, this was a headline from Florida this morning — the legislature is going to turn back child labor laws so 14 year olds can work later shifts. Arkansas and Iowa legislatures rolled back child labor laws last year, so this will be a red state trend.
https://www.cnn.com/2025/03/25/business/florida-child-labor-laws/index.html
Did Steven Miller direct HSI Denver to re-classify these aliens arrested in Bigfork as illegal in their report?
Do you recall the name of the concrete contractor in Kalispell?
Your friend the contractor can’t get people even with his “show up” bonus, because he isn’t paying wages that Americans are willing to work for. The solution to that should not be “replace Americans” but pay higher wages (Rather than your contractor friend paying lower wages and the taxpayers picking up a massive bill for social services.) There is no such thing as a job “Americans won’t do.” They just won’t do some very tough jobs for very little money.
Will hiring American raise prices? In some cases– but America will save massive amounts of money from not having to pay social services for illegals– and our cultural cohesion will increase.
Well said, Roy!
Thanks, Roger!
[…] been crusading for in order to transform Missoula into a more diverse community for her children. A recent piece at Western Montana News shows that my unpopular perspective has the potential to get MORE unpopular if the numbers of […]
I have been seeing this for years. Illegals are filtered all over Montana, and small communities have also suffered. Good on you for pointing it out. Our young people need jobs as well as homes. This article is uplifting, knowing people will stand up to the leftist agenda in Missoula. They ruined a once beautiful town with ugly housing meant for a big city. Research the companies that hired these illegals and make sure everyone in Montana knows who they are.
Thanks, Connie!
Well a good place for Ag Kudnsen and ICE to start removing them is the hotels in Missoula. As well many businesses have them working for them. As soon as President Trump and Tom Holman announced removals I saw a huge influx of them in this county. I am beyond over of paying for other’s.